Now Reading
The New York City Council Passed a Ban on Surveillance Pricing

The New York City Council Passed a Ban on Surveillance Pricing

A person with a full basket of groceries, at the fresh produce section of a grocery store. They are reaching for some green produce.

The New York City Council passed a bill that bans surveillance pricing. This is a huge move in consumer rights, privacy, and fair pricing. The bill, known as Introduction 891-A, prohibits businesses from using New Yorkers’ personal information to set individualized prices. This bill applies to all five boroughs.

New York City’s Mayor Zohran Mamdani is set to sign the bill into law after it passed on November 12. Speaker Julie Menin sponsored the legislation to the council.

What Is Surveillance Pricing?

Surveillance pricing is a newer practice for businesses to maximize profit. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), “businesses [use] consumers’ detailed personal information… location, demographics, and browsing history—to categorize individuals and set targeted prices…”

Surveillance pricing is “invisible” to consumers and hard to identify. A report from Groundwork Collaborative and Consumer Reports presents in-depth research on the problem, especially in grocery delivery services like Instacart. One example shows the prices for different Target shoppers on the same basket of groceries: “…$84.43, $84.81, $84.92, and $90.47…”

These prices are based on an algorithm and charge people different prices for the same product or service. This is not only unfair to shoppers but also gives businesses the upper hand in profiting from how each consumer’s personal data affects their spending. It directly contributes to the growing affordability crisis.

What Does This Mean for Shoppers?

New York City is one of the biggest examples of the countrywide affordability crisis. This leaves many Americans living paycheck to paycheck, juggling multiple jobs, and facing layoffs.

Council speaker and bill sponsor Menin clarified what the ban means for the consumer. “The City Council is putting consumers first by ending the deceptive and insidious practice of surveillance pricing. When corporations use algorithms and personal data to charge different people using different prices for the same products, it’s unethical and worsens our affordability crisis. We take consumer protection extremely seriously, and we will continue fighting to lower prices and stop predatory corporate tactics.”

The New York City Council’s website explains what violating this bill entails and the reparations consumers will receive. The bill would give the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection “the ability to investigate complaints and issue fines of up to $1,000 for each violation.” The bill also allows small businesses to avoid fines through corrective action “if violations are promptly addressed.” Consumers can also receive legitimate and transparent discounts and rewards.

Council Member Harvey Epstein, Chair of the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, explained the issues with surveillance pricing in more detail. “…when pricing is based on personal and biometric data, which is exactly what surveillance pricing relies on, the probability of discrimination skyrockets.”

See Also
Movie theater crowd reacting

This Is Only the Beginning

These are early signs of a hopeful future where consumer protections take priority over profit. Just last month, Seattle became the first U.S. city to ban surveillance pricing via the Fair Pricing and Transparency Ordinance. Seattle City Mayor Katie Wilson said, “Everyone deserves transparent pricing and equal treatment, not hidden systems that charge some shoppers more than others.”

Multiple states are considering bans and restrictions on surveillance pricing, but consumers are picking up on these practices fast. Trust in companies that use surveillance pricing is wearing thin, and more consumers are questioning the prices taped to shelves.

Let’s just hope that it never comes to a banana costing $10.

What's Your Reaction?
Excited
0
Happy
0
In Love
0
Not Sure
0
Silly
0
View Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

OUR PARTNERS



JUSTNLIFE.com is part of Nekia Nichelle, LLC. Just N Life may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
©2023 Nekia Nichelle, LLC. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | JustNLife.com Advertising Terms



Scroll To Top